My
philosophy is very fluid at the moment, and I am sure that it will change
dramatically in a short span of time.
For this post I am going to focus on the ideals that I have seen to be
true, what I have learned through class discussion, and what I predict will be
true when I apply my teaching philosophy. When it comes to teaching composition
there are three basic things that I believe:
1. People write the best when they thoroughly
understand the topic
2. People want to explore topics that
are relevant to their lives and experiences
3. When people are asked to express what
they care about, they will take time and do it properly.
It has
become apparent to me, while grading, that students write best about topics
they understand. Therefore, if the main focus is teaching them to write clearly,
it seems reasonable to start with writing about things they know: themselves,
their interests, and their experiences. In
high school they are asked to study literature, and most of them do not read
the books they are analyzing. They are asked to recount the events of history,
and other complex topics. While it is
important for them to analyze literature and learn history, the topics can
overshadow the writing. Their own style
and ability to construct a sentence will come easier if they do not also have
to grapple with a topic they know little about.
After their writing skills are mature, then they can start working with
more complicated subjects and the different types of writing. If they fully understand their own writing
process, it will be easier for them to identify the choices another writer makes. Furthermore, this will demonstrate to them
the importance of understanding the topics they are asked to write about. I think that much of the weak writing we see
stems from the students failing to comprehend the subject matter. When they are asked to work with more
difficult texts, they must realize that they can only write about them well if
they understand them thoroughly.
Next, there
can be no denying that when a topic is interesting or relevant, the learners
will engage with the subject. We had an
interesting discussion in class about how achievable relevant topics are on a
daily basis. From this discussion I
concluded that every lesson is in fact relevant, but maybe not in the way we
would hope. If we know that a day’s
topic is particularly dry, I think it is important to discuss that with the
students; they are adults now, and with that comes responsibility and having do
things they do not want to do. Whether
every class is enthralling or not, the students are responsible for learning
the information if they want to succeed.
Being able to work through the uninteresting aspects of a class or job
and still be engaged enough to succeed is an important skill. Obviously, it would be better if every class
was intriguing, but there will be slow days and the students need to learn how
to work with those days. Also, we cannot
fully comprehend how our lessons will be relevant to every single person every day.
I think a useful exercise would be to start asking the students how the material
is relevant to them. This will give them responsibility and control over what
they get out of the class, and will get them involved on the days when the
lesson is dry or the class seems disinterested.
Finally,
students will engage in what they are passionate about. If they are given topics that they care about
they will take the time and do them properly.
As a teacher, I can provide new information and lead discussion, but I cannot
direct what they care about. Students
want to express themselves, and it is the teacher’s job to show them how. They will want to write clearly and thoroughly
if they are writing about something they are passionate about. If we can help them realize that the skills
we are teaching them in 1301 will help them express their views in the real
world, they will want to learn.
Jill,
ReplyDeleteThere is no doubt that students do a better job writing about something they care about. Part of my teaching philosophy also deals with helping students make connections between what we learn in class and what happens in their daily lives.
Its also true that sometimes we have to teach topics that are dryer than others. I would caution against telling students that "I know this is really dry." ( I may or may not be speaking from experience here). While students may appreciate the honesty, they sometimes take it as a permission to check out, and class participation is abysmal. If I have to teach a topic I find especially dry, I try to find ways to get excited (or at least feign excitement) about the topic myself. If I'm bored, my students are definitely going to be bored. That said, you are absolutely correct that students have to learn to do things they don't want to do. There's a fine balance between engaging students and watering down the material.
Hi Jill - Very interesting reading your teaching philosophy, especially as you connect it to our in-class discussion on Friday. I think it's really valuable that you would put the onus on the students to figure out how a text is relevant to them. This can be very generative. What about the students, though, who will be aloof and simply say "It isn't relevant to me."? What tools should we have to push back on this kind of laconic response and keep the classroom lively?
ReplyDeleteAs a poet, do you hope to teach creative writing? How does that relate to what you say about students expressing themselves better when they write what they care about? I am very interested in how to get students moving from navel-gazing poetry and prose that is all about them into writing about larger societal issues that they relate to.
Hey Jill. I agree with you completely on needing to make the material relevant to students. It's also important, I think, to keep the material relevant to the world as well and sometimes students need to accept the fact that it's not always going to be about them and how something relates to them.
ReplyDeleteTrue that. There's a subtle difference between "important to the students" and "important in the bigger picture," but maybe part of teaching can be to nudge those realms of importance a little closer together.
DeleteGreat post! I completely agree with finding ways of relating your classroom material to your students; however, I agree with MaryAnn that occasionally being too honest with your students could backfire and be devastating to classroom morale. I really like your first point and its concern for finding things that the student cares about. I believe that as educators we should seek to find ways to use the tools and activities students are already involved in to improve the overall classroom experience.
ReplyDelete